9 Best Cozy Cape Cod Restaurants with a Fireplace 2024

Where can you relax by a fire  on Cape Cod ? Here are some of our favorite bars and restaurants with fireplaces. fun fact Dinner always taste better by a fireplace

The Pheasant Inn Dennis

A charming, historic restaurant  known for its cozy ambiance. There are the two warm fireplaces located in the Red Pheasant inn , the delicious wine, beer, and cocktails, plus an exciting menu options.

The Barley Neck Inn Orleans

Based in an old 1868 sea captains home in East Orleans, Joe’s Beach Bar and Grille at The Barley Neck Inn has been recognized by Yankee Magazine, Boston Globe and USA Today. With four intimate dining rooms and year-round entertainment, the warm atmosphere with the fire place  is perfect for any winter night.

Courtyard Restaurant and Pub  Cataumet

Voted best in entertainment two years Cape Cod Life Magazine, the Courtyard Restaurant and Pub in Cataumet (one of Bourne’s 9 villages)  is a great spot that offers both quiet and intimate dining during the week, as well as lively music and drinks on the weekend. Get there early to secure the corner booth next to the warm and crackling fire place.

Scargo Cafe Dennis 

Scargo Cafe in Dennis upgraded their already warm and comforting atmosphere to include a brick-face fireplace. Scargo is famous for their expertly crafted menu that changes seasonally to include fresh and local produce and seafood.  Reservations are offered but in an effort to maintain a casual, “come as you are” informal feel, we still keep exactly half of our tables open and available on a “first come” basis. Everyone loves Scargo Cafe and often times there may be a wait for a table. It is difficult to predict wait times or walk-in table availability but we promise that we will never turn anyone away. Come join us!

The Dolphin Restaurant in Barnstable

The Dolphin was started 70 years ago by the current owner Nancy Smith’s grandparents and has been a landmark in Barnstable Village ever since. A hands-on restaurant for three generations, patrons will always be greeted by a friendly face who often knows your name.  There’s a  warm cozy fireplace  during the winter months in their formal dinning room. They also have a bar as well

Wimpy’s Restaurant Osterville

Founded in 1938, Wimpy’s Restaurant presents a menu of classic Cape Cod dishes  showcasing fresh seafood and inventive comfort cuisine. The inviting ambiance encompasses a vibrant pub, two dining rooms with fireplaces, and a Seafood Market offering takeout services. Situated in the picturesque village of Osterville on Cape Cod, the restaurant promises a charming dining experience.

Stars  Restaurant at Chatham Bars Inn

At Stars, relish breathtaking panoramic vistas overlooking Chatham Harbor and the Atlantic Ocean. Drawing inspiration from these splendid views, the natural environment, and the richness of the Chatham Bars Inn farm, they  seamlessly fuse regional heritage with contemporary coastal-inspired cuisine. Infused with history, the ambiance features Norman Rockwell’s “Spirit of America” gracing the fireplace, making STARS an immersive experience that captivates all the senses. By reinterpreting timeless dishes, they pay homage to the inn’s legacy, crafting a menu that intertwines the past with the present. With an acclaimed wine selection, authentic hospitality, and tailored service, we extend a warm invitation for you to commence your mornings and conclude your evenings with Cape Cod’s premier dining encounter.

Thoreau’s at Wequassett Resort Harwich

Thoreau’s provides the perfect setting for a cozy lunch or dinner, presenting menus that offer a distinctive twist on familiar classics. Unwind beside the inviting fireplace while savoring cocktails and indulging in expertly grilled seafood. As you sit by the warmth of the fire, glance through the windows for a glimpse of the nearby sea, adding an extra touch to your dining experience.

The Roscommon Room at Ocean Edge Resort Brewster

The Roscommon Room offers a unique dining experience for both lunch and dinner at Ocean Edge Resort, situated behind The Mansion with a stunning view of Cape Cod Bay. Visitors and diners are welcome to reserve a table within the restaurant for a classic à-la-carte dining experience, where they can relish wintry cocktails alongside a variety of seasonal starters and entrees, ranging from lobster poutine to butternut squash risotto. Additionally, guests can enjoy comfortable seating by the fireplace or within the bar area.

Montano’s Restaurant Truro

A well-established restaurant and bar situated by the bay in Truro , offering a menu featuring classic Italian cuisine and locally sourced seafood. The dining area is both cozy and captivating, featuring a spacious stone fireplace and barn-board walls adorned with vintage family photos. On one wall, a display of assorted plates adds to the charm, while plants gracefully dangle from the rafters.

Gerardi’s Cafe

Italian restaurant located in South Yarmouth that is open year round! Has Early bird specials’ during the winter months.  Upon entering the  restaurant, you are greeted by its enchanting ambiance, adorned with captivating artwork, a cozy fireplace, flickering candles, and a mix of booths and tables dressed in tablecloths.

Encore Bistro & Bar in Dennis Village